Video Transcript
Have you ever stopped to ask yourself: Are the grades I’m giving even real? Are they actually telling you and your students what they need to know about progress? In this video, we’ll dive into how you can ensure your grades are accurate reflections of student learning, and I’ll give you practical steps to improve the reliability and validity of your grading system.
HI friends, I'm Matthew Courtney and here we talk all about education research and data. If you're into that, make sure you like and subscribe and come be a part of our community.
Today we’re talking about two key concepts when it comes to grading: reliability and validity. Reliability means that your grades are consistent—students would get the same grade if they took the same test on a different day or if another teacher graded their work. Validity, on the other hand, is about accuracy—making sure that the grade actually measures what the student has learned, not just their effort or participation.
If grades aren’t reliable or valid, they can give students—and you—false signals about their progress. Let’s break down what that means and how you can ensure your grades are meaningful reflections of student learning.
Let’s start with reliability. Reliability means that a student’s grade should be consistent no matter when you assess their work or who is doing the grading. For example, if you grade a student’s essay today and give it a B, but grade it again tomorrow and give it a C, that’s a sign of unreliable grading. This can happen when subjective factors like your mood, time pressure, or personal biases sneak into the grading process, leading to inconsistent results.
To improve reliability, you need to remove as much subjectivity as possible from your grading. One way to do this is by using clear, detailed rubrics that outline specific criteria for each grade level. When your expectations are clear—both to you and to your students—it’s easier to be consistent across different assignments, students, and even different days. Rubrics make it less likely that emotions or external factors will influence your judgment.
Additionally, consider grading a few assignments together before you start grading an entire class set. This helps calibrate your mindset and ensures you’re applying the same standards across the board. By focusing on consistency in how you apply your grading criteria, you’ll create a more reliable system that reflects true student performance every time.
Now, let’s talk about validity. Validity means that the grade accurately reflects what the student has actually learned, not just their effort, participation, or behavior. For example, if your goal is to assess a student’s understanding of a math concept, but your grade is influenced by how neatly they completed the assignment, then the grade isn’t truly valid. It’s not measuring what you intended—student mastery of the subject.
To ensure your grades are valid, make sure your assessments are directly aligned with the learning objectives. If you want to measure a student’s ability to analyze a text, then your assessment should focus on their analysis skills, not just their ability to recall facts or organize their work. Be clear about what skills or knowledge you’re assessing, and make sure that’s what’s being reflected in the grade.
Another way to improve validity is by using multiple forms of assessment—quizzes, projects, essays—so that you’re measuring a range of skills. This helps give a more accurate picture of a student’s true abilities, and it ensures that grades represent the knowledge and skills they’ve developed, not just their ability to complete one type of task.
It is important that you continually track and monitor your grading process to ensure reliability and validity throughout the year. A key way to improve both reliability and validity is by using data to track and monitor your grading. Collect data on how students perform across different types of assessments—do students consistently perform well or poorly in certain areas? Look for patterns that might indicate inconsistencies in your grading or areas where the assessments don’t fully reflect what students know. If you notice big discrepancies between different assignments, it might be a sign that either your assessments or grading criteria need adjustment.
To do this effectively, create a simple data tracking system that allows you to compare student performance across assignments. Are there any major jumps or dips in grades? For example, if a student’s grade suddenly drops significantly on one assessment, ask yourself if the issue lies with the student’s understanding or with the assessment or grading method itself. Analyzing this data regularly can help you adjust your grading practices in real time, making sure you’re consistently reflecting student progress.
Additionally, comparing data between different groups of students, such as different classes or demographics, can help ensure your grading is fair and equitable. This step allows you to spot any unintentional biases and work toward a more consistent and valid grading system.
It is also important to step back and reflect on what grades are really supposed to represent. Grades should be a meaningful reflection of what students know and are able to do. If your grades are based on factors that don’t directly measure learning, like effort or behavior, they may not be providing a true picture of student progress. Ask yourself: Are the grades I’m giving helping students understand where they are in their learning journey? Are they motivating students to improve in meaningful ways?
One practical way to ensure grades are fulfilling their purpose is to engage students in self-assessment and peer feedback. When students understand how they’re being assessed and can reflect on their own progress, they take more ownership of their learning. This also allows them to see that grades are not just numbers but tools to guide improvement.
Ultimately, grades should be tools for both students and teachers to track learning and growth. Reflect on your grading philosophy and make sure it aligns with these goals. When your grades are reliable, valid, and aligned with the purpose of measuring student learning, they become a powerful tool for student success.
So, are your grades real? By focusing on both reliability and validity, you can ensure that the grades you give truly reflect what your students know and can do. Remember, reliable grades are consistent, and valid grades measure the right things. By using clear rubrics, aligning assessments with learning objectives, tracking data, and reflecting on your grading practices, you can create a grading system that helps students grow and succeed.
If you found value in this video today, make sure you like and subscribe and check out some of the other videos on my channel. I’ll see you next time.
Comentarios